According to National Review, California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration secretly imposed a statewide fracking ban, denied its existence for years, then invoked environmental justifications contradicted by its own earlier findings.
Reportedly, this ban was recently exposed by a California judge.
In an October 8 tentative ruling, Superior Court Judge Bernard Barmann Jr. invalidated both the administration’s secret prohibition on fracking, imposed in 2021, and the formal regulation adopted in 2024. The ruling is a legal embarrassment for Newsom and an indictment of California’s increasingly arbitrary approach to energy policy.
The story begins in 2019, when Newsom told disappointed supporters that he lacked authority to impose a fracking moratorium. “You can’t do that unilaterally,” he said. “Legally, you cannot. The governor of California cannot do that.”
Apparently, he reconsidered. In 2021, after legislation to ban fracking failed in a Democrat-controlled Senate committee, Newsom’s office quietly directed the California Geologic Energy Management Division, or CalGEM, to stop approving well-stimulation permits.
But getting his regulators to carry out his order was another matter. In 2019, Newsom fired state oil and gas supervisor Ken Harris amid complaints that his agency had approved too many fracking permits. Harris’s replacement, Uduak-Joe Ntuk, continued evaluating applications, approving 83 well-stimulation permits in 2020 while denying 57. Even after Newsom announced plans to ban fracking, Ntuk’s agency approved another twelve permits in 2021.
That changed in July 2021, when CalGEM began categorically denying applications rather than evaluating each on its merits. In letters to oil producers, Ntuk cited climate change, public health, and environmental protection to justify rejecting their permit applications.
[…]
For the next two years, the administration denied that any such prohibition existed. Its lawyers assured the court that allegations of a ban were “hyperbole and speculation.” Then came an extraordinary admission. In October 2024, CalGEM admitted that it had imposed a shadow ban to avoid the legally required rulemaking process.
Read the full story in National Review.


