Can Colorado Use State Law to Hold American Energy Companies Responsible for Climate Change?

The Supreme Court case Suncor Energy v. Boulder County will decide if a local jurisdiction can use state law to hold American energy companies financially responsible for the alleged effects of worldwide greenhouse gas emissions. 

While the case began in Colorado, the outcome will impact the entire nation, warned Chris Johnson, founder and president of the American Energy Leadership Institute, in the Washington Examiner. 

Boulder sued Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil, arguing that the companies’ production and promotion of fossil fuels contributed to climate change and caused local damage. They are seeking money for costs associated with wildfires, severe weather, infrastructure, and other alleged climate-related harms. 

Climate change is a global issue. Greenhouse gas emissions do not stop at the Colorado border, and they cannot be separated by state or traced neatly to one company. Boulder’s claims depend on energy production, sales, and emissions occurring across the country and around the world. China, India, and Russia remain far beyond the reach of this suit even though their industrial economies produce goods with far higher emissions. 

A Colorado courtroom cannot resolve that problem. It can only impose financial penalties on a small group of American companies for a global phenomenon while dirtier foreign competitors escape every penalty. That is regulation by lawsuit. 

One of the Boulder plaintiffs’ own lawyers has described tort liability as an “indirect carbon tax.” His larger admission matters: Consumers would bear the resulting costs. That strips away the legal packaging and reveals what this litigation is designed to accomplish. 

Read the full story in the Washington Examiner.  

Share this article:

Related Posts